Pressed Cane vs. Hand Caning: What’s the Difference?

If your chair has a cane seat that’s sagging, split, or has a hole you can put your foot through (or one your kid already put their foot through), the first question is which kind of cane it has. There are two main types: pressed cane vs hand caning. Pressed cane (also called sheet cane or cane webbing) is woven by machine into a sheet, then pressed into a groove around the seat and held in place with a strip called a spline. Hand caning is woven right on the chair, one strand at a time, through a row of holes drilled around the seat. They can look nearly the same from across the room. Up close, and in how they get repaired, they’re very different.

Hand caned seat

Pressed cane seat

One strand at a time

When people visit the studio and watch hand caning in progress, this is the part that surprises them. There’s no sheet and no shortcut. It’s a series of single long strands of cane, threaded down through one hole, across the seat, and up through the hole on the other side, then back again, over and over. The pattern you know, with its little octagonal openings, is built in layers:

  1. Verticals. Strands run front to back across the whole seat.
  2. Horizontals. Strands run side to side, laid over the first layer.
  3. Second verticals. Another front-to-back layer, placed just beside the first.
  4. Second horizontals. This is the first layer that’s actually woven, over and under, through what’s already there.
  5. First diagonals. Strands run corner to corner, weaving through everything.
  6. Second diagonals. The opposite direction, which locks the whole pattern together.

Then a wider strand called a binder is laid around the edge to cover the holes and finish it off.

Every strand gets wetted to keep it pliable, pulled snug, and pegged to hold tension while the next row goes in. A dining chair seat takes many hours, and nothing about it can be rushed. Most people are floored when they realize that the whole seat is just one strand after another.

Pressed cane isn’t “fake” cane

Pressed cane gets a bad reputation it doesn’t deserve. It’s real cane, the same material, and factories have used it since the late 1800s. Plenty of good chairs were made for it, including a lot of the mid-century pieces we see. It’s quicker to install, which is part of why it became standard on production furniture.

The difference is in how it’s built and how it fails. Pressed cane is a single sheet held by the spline, so when it breaks, the whole sheet gets cut out and replaced.

How to tell which one you have

Flip the chair over or look closely at the edge of the seat:

  • A groove with a thin strip of reed pressed into it running around the opening: that’s pressed cane. The strip is the spline.
  • A row of small drilled holes around the opening, with cane looped between them on the underside: that’s hand caning.
  • No cane at all, but a woven cord or twisted fiber seat: that’s probably Danish cord or rush, a different craft (a different post and additional types of weaving we thoroughly enjoy).

Can I switch from one to the other?

Usually not, and usually you shouldn’t. The chair was built for one method. A pressed cane frame has a groove and no holes, and a hand-caned frame has holes and no groove. Turning one into the other means cutting into the original frame, which changes the piece. Our general rule is that the chair decides. We restore it the way it was made.

Which one costs more?

Cost does vary between pressed cane vs hand caning. Hand caning, by a fair margin, because it’s all labor. A pressed cane replacement is a matter of cutting out the old sheet, cleaning the groove, and setting a new one. A hand-caned seat is woven from nothing, strand by strand. Price depends on the size of the seat or the number of holes, so the easiest way to know is to send us a photo of the top and underside of the seat.

Bringing a chair in

We do pressed cane, hand caning, Danish cord, and rush seating at our studio just south of downtown Columbus. If you’re not sure what you have, send a photo or book a visit, and we’ll tell you what it is and what it needs. And if you’ve never seen hand caning in progress, just ask. It’s worth seeing.


Response

  1. […] If your cane is already sagging or broken, oil won’t bring it back, but we can. See our refinishing and chair caning services, or book a studio visit and bring the chair by. Not sure what kind of cane you have? Start with pressed cane vs. hand caning. […]